Workplace Psychological Contracts: What They Are and Why They Matter

-

In today's ever-evolving work environment, organizations are increasingly realizing the importance of intangible factors that influence employee satisfaction, performance, and overall engagement. One such critical concept is the psychological contract – a term that refers to the unwritten set of expectations, beliefs, and mutual obligations between employers and employees.

What is a Psychological Contract?

The term "psychological contract" was first introduced by organizational scholar Chris Argyris in the 1960s and later expanded by other researchers such as Denise Rousseau. Unlike formal, written contracts that outline specific terms of employment, the psychological contract is based on mutual expectations and trust between employers and employees. It involves the beliefs both parties hold regarding their obligations to each other, and it can significantly affect employee behavior and organizational outcomes.

Types of Psychological Contracts

Psychological contracts can be divided into two main types:

  1. Transactional Psychological Contracts: These are short-term, based on monetary rewards and tangible benefits. They emphasize immediate returns in exchange for work done. Employees who operate under this type of contract are primarily motivated by pay and job security, while employers expect efficient performance without much emotional or long-term commitment.
  2. Relational Psychological Contracts: These contracts are more long-term and emotional. They include a commitment to the organization, career development, and mutual trust. Employees with a relational psychological contract expect recognition, development opportunities, and a sense of belonging, while employers expect loyalty, engagement, and high performance over time.

Why Do Psychological Contracts Matter?

Psychological contracts play a crucial role in shaping employee satisfaction and organizational commitment. When expectations are aligned, employees tend to feel valued, supported, and motivated. On the flip side, breaches in the psychological contract can lead to disengagement, decreased productivity, and higher turnover rates.

A breach occurs when an employee feels that the organization has not fulfilled its part of the deal – for instance, failing to provide promised career advancement or work-life balance. Similarly, employees might also breach their psychological contract by not living up to expectations, such as underperforming or displaying a lack of commitment. These breaches can result in feelings of betrayal, distrust, and diminished morale.

The Impact of Psychological Contracts on Employee Behavior

  1. Engagement: A positive psychological contract promotes a higher level of employee engagement. When employees feel their contributions are recognized and they are receiving the support they need, they are more likely to go above and beyond in their roles.
  2. Job Satisfaction: Aligning expectations can lead to better job satisfaction, reducing turnover rates and absenteeism.
  3. Performance: Employees who trust their employer and feel valued tend to perform better, as they are more motivated and invested in the organization's success.

  1. Trust: The psychological contract relies heavily on mutual trust. When trust is broken – either by the employer or employee – the work environment can become toxic, leading to conflict, reduced morale, and disengagement.

The Impact of Netflix’s Leave Retraction Policy on the Psychological Contract

Netflix recently introduced a controversial leave retraction policy, which allows the company to revoke employees’ time off requests even after they’ve been approved. This shift in policy, which surprised many employees, offers a clear example of how changes to organizational practices can affect the psychological contract between employer and employee.

When employees request time off, they are often doing so based on an understanding that the company values their well-being and will support them in achieving work-life balance. However, Netflix's leave retraction policy sends the opposite message: that the company reserves the right to revoke time off, potentially disrupting employees' personal plans and undermining the trust they've placed in the organization.

This policy change can be seen as a breach of the psychological contract for many employees, particularly those who have come to rely on the company's earlier policies regarding leave. For employees, trust is a critical part of their relationship with their employer, and this move could make them feel like their personal time and well-being are secondary to the company's needs. Such breaches can lead to lower employee engagement, decreased job satisfaction, and even higher turnover if employees feel their expectations are no longer aligned with the company's values.

For Netflix, the decision to implement this policy highlights the tension between flexibility and control in a modern work environment. While the company might justify the policy change based on business needs, it's important to recognize that employees may interpret this as a violation of the implicit contract of trust. The challenge for Netflix and other companies with similar policies will be to find a balance between operational needs and respecting employees' expectations.

Managing Psychological Contracts Effectively

For employers, managing psychological contracts effectively involves:

  • Clear Communication: Open, transparent communication is vital to ensure that both parties have a clear understanding of expectations. Regular feedback and check-ins can help keep the psychological contract in alignment.
  • Fulfillment of Promises: Organizations should be careful about making promises they cannot keep. Ensuring that commitments related to career development, rewards, and work-life balance are met is key to maintaining trust.
  • Flexibility and Adaptability: As the nature of work evolves, so do the expectations of employees. Offering flexible work arrangements, career development opportunities, and fostering a culture of trust and respect can help maintain a positive psychological contract. However, policies like leave retraction must be handled carefully to avoid breaching trust.

For employees, honoring the psychological contract means:

  • Transparency: Being clear about their needs and expectations with the employer, and being proactive in communicating when those expectations are not being met.
  • Commitment: Demonstrating loyalty, strong work ethics, and a willingness to contribute to the organization’s success.
  • Adaptability: Recognizing that the psychological contract may evolve, especially in times of organizational change, and being flexible with expectations.

Real-World Examples of Psychological Contract Breach

  1. Google: The tech giant is known for its open work culture and strong employee benefits. However, in recent years, some employees have raised concerns about the company's shift in policies around remote work and benefits. A breach of their perceived psychological contract can result in decreased morale or even increased attrition.
  2. Retail Industry: Employees in the retail sector may expect consistent hours and job security. When an employer cuts hours or offers limited benefits, employees may feel their psychological contract has been breached, leading to disengagement or high turnover rates.

Psychological contracts are foundational to building a positive, engaged workforce. Both employers and employees must recognize the importance of these unwritten expectations and ensure they are met. Organizations that understand and manage psychological contracts effectively can foster a culture of trust, engagement, and long-term success. On the other hand, ignoring or violating these contracts can lead to dissatisfaction, disengagement, and high turnover.

Netflix’s leave retraction policy serves as a reminder that even well-established companies must carefully consider the impact of their decisions on the psychological contract with their employees. By investing in maintaining a healthy psychological contract, employers can create a more motivated, loyal, and productive workforce.

Ready to Strengthen Your Talent Strategy?

Looking to improve your leadership strategies and support employee mental health? Biz Coach Gurus offers customized solutions for small businesses. Visit www.bizcoachgurus.com to learn how we can help!

At BizCoachGurus, we specialize in HR strategy, talent development, and workplace solutions to help businesses create environments where employees thrive.

Contact us today at BizCoachGurus.com to learn how we can help you build a workforce that stays and succeeds!

📩 Email: BizCoachGurus@gmail.com
📞 Call: 347-693-3399
🌐 Visit: www.BizCoachGurus.com

Sources:

  1. Rousseau, D. M. (1995). Psychological Contracts in Organizations: Understanding Written and Unwritten Agreements. Sage.
  2. Conway, N., & Briner, R. B. (2005). Understanding Psychological Contracts at Work: A Critical Evaluation of Theory and Research. Oxford University Press.
  3. Robinson, S. P., & Morrison, E. W. (2000). The Development of Psychological Contract Breach and Violation: A Longitudinal Study. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 21(5), 525-546.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Starting an HR Department: A Guide for Small Businesses

-
Image
As a small business grows, it becomes increasingly important to establish a dedicated Human Resources (HR) department. Having an HR function ensures that your organization complies with labor laws, supports employees, and fosters a positive workplace culture. However, building an HR department from scratch can be a daunting task for small businesses. This guide will help you understand the essential steps to create an HR department that can support both your current needs and your growth. 1. Assess Your HR Needs Before you dive into creating an HR department, it’s important to understand your organization’s current and future needs. Start by evaluating the size of your company, the nature of your workforce, and the complexities of your operations. If your company has fewer than 50 employees, your HR needs may be relatively basic, such as handling payroll and recruiting. However, as your company grows, you may need to focus on compliance, employee relations, and benefits administration....
Read more

How to Design an Employee Benefits Program

-
Image
According to SHRM, selecting the best benefit plan involves first identifying your organization's benefits objectives and budget, then conducting a thorough needs assessment to understand employee preferences, before formulating a plan that aligns with those needs while staying within budget constraints; key factors to consider include: employee demographics, desired benefits, cost-effectiveness, and clear communication of the plan to employees.  Key steps outlined by SHRM to select the best benefit plan: Assess employee needs: Conduct surveys, focus groups, or one-on-one meetings to understand what benefits are most important to your workforce and their varying demographics.  Set a budget: Determine how much your organization can allocate towards employee benefits.  Consider different benefit categories: Evaluate options like health insurance, retirement savings plans, life insurance, disability coverage, paid time off, and flexible work arrangements.  Compare plan ...
Read more

Understanding the Difference Between Exempt and Non-Exempt Employees

-
Image
Properly classifying employees as exempt or non-exempt is crucial for businesses to comply with the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) and avoid potential legal issues. The primary distinction between these classifications lies in overtime pay eligibility.  And unfortunately, many small businesses and new owners find themselves having to navigate making these decisions very early on in their business.   Here are some helpful ways to understand the differences: Non-Exempt Employees Non-exempt employees are entitled to: Minimum Wage : At least the federal minimum wage for each hour worked. Overtime Pay : Time-and-a-half for hours worked over 40 in a workweek. These protections are mandated by the FLSA. Exempt Employees Exempt employees are not entitled to overtime pay. To qualify as exempt, employees generally must meet specific criteria: Salary Level: Earn a minimum amount per week. Salary Basis: Receive a fixed salary not subject to reduction based on work quality or quanti...
Read more