He's the First One In and the Last to Leave. So what could possibly be wrong?

-

 

He's the First One In and the Last to Leave. So What Could Possibly Be Wrong?

You know the employee. Early to every shift, first to volunteer for a teammate's overflow, never a complaint about staying late. On paper, a manager's dream.

And yet: deadlines slip. Deliverables come back needing significant rework. When a problem pops up mid-project, he waits for direction instead of running with it.

If you're a manager sitting with this exact contradiction right now, you're not imagining it, and you're not wrong to be confused by it. What you're looking at isn't a motivation problem. It's a Skill vs. Will problem, and the two require completely different fixes.

The Framework: Will Is Not the Same as Skill

The Skill/Will matrix (originated by Max Landsberg) sorts every performance issue into one of two axes:

  • Will: motivation, attitude, effort, commitment
  • Skill: competence, experience, technical ability to execute the specific task

Most managers, understandably, read effort as a proxy for capability. If someone's working hard, we assume the results will follow. But an employee can sit in the "high will, low skill" quadrant indefinitely, showing up with genuine commitment while still lacking the judgment, technical know-how, or experience to independently plan, prioritize, or self-correct their work.

This is the person who needs direction and development, not more encouragement. Praising effort alone doesn't teach someone how to triage a deadline or where to start when a task is ambiguous, no matter how many times you thank them for staying late.

Why This Gets Missed So Often

The data suggests this isn't a rare blind spot, it's a structural one.

Fewer than half of managers worldwide have ever received formal management training, according to Gallup research, meaning most managers are diagnosing performance gaps on instinct rather than any structured coaching model. Gallup has also found that a manager's weakest self-rated and peer-rated area is specifically the "coaching habit," one of the strongest known predictors of employee engagement. In other words, the very skill needed to tell the difference between a will problem and a skill problem is the one managers are least equipped for.

The employee side of the equation compounds it. Multiple workforce surveys put the share of employees who want more feedback than they currently get at around two-thirds, and roughly a third report waiting longer than three months to hear anything substantive from their manager. A high-will, low-skill employee left in that silence doesn't get worse because he stops caring. He gets worse because no one has told him what "good" looks like or shown him how to get there. He keeps doing what he knows how to do (show up, help, try hard) because that's the only lever he's been shown.

The upside case is just as clear. Forrester's 2025 Future of Work data found employees are over eight times more likely to be highly engaged when they see their manager as a coach rather than a boss. Coaching isn't a soft nice-to-have here, it's the actual mechanism that moves someone out of the high-will, low-skill quadrant.

The Risk of Getting the Diagnosis Wrong

Two failure modes show up constantly with this exact profile:

  1. Managers wait too long, hoping effort will convert to competence on its own. It usually doesn't, not without a change in how the work is scoped, taught, or checked.
  2. Managers eventually escalate straight to a performance write-up, which reads to the employee (accurately) as punishment for something no one ever tried to teach them. This is often where your hardest, most loyal workers quietly disengage or leave, not because they didn't want to grow, but because no one showed them how.

Neither serves the employee, the manager, or the business. The fix is a deliberate coaching conversation, not more patience and not premature discipline.

5 Things You Can Do Today

  1. Name the gap out loud, separately from effort. In your next 1:1, explicitly separate the two: "Your commitment and work ethic aren't in question. I want to talk specifically about how we get your project timelines and deliverables to match that same standard." This prevents the employee from hearing "you're not good enough" when the real message is "let's build a skill."

  2. Diagnose the specific skill gap, not the general one. "Not meeting deadlines" and "not meeting quality expectations" are symptoms, not diagnoses. Is it prioritization? Not knowing when to ask for help? Not understanding what "done" looks like? Sit down together and reconstruct one recent missed deadline step-by-step to find where it actually broke down.

  3. Replace "let me know if you need anything" with a structured checkpoint. High-will, low-skill employees often won't ask for help, asking can feel like admitting failure. Build in a scheduled mid-point check-in on every assignment for the next 60–90 days rather than waiting for them to flag a problem.

  4. Teach the judgment, not just the task. If initiative is the gap, don't just tell him what to do next time, show him how you decided what to do this time. Narrate your own decision-making on a live example so he can start building the same internal checklist.

  5. Set one measurable target and revisit it in two weeks, not six months. Pick a single, specific, observable behavior (e.g., "flag any blocker within 24 hours" or "submit a rough draft two days before the deadline for review"). A short feedback loop matters more than the size of the ask: employees who connect with their manager frequently show measurably higher engagement than those who don't.

The Bottom Line

Work ethic earns trust. It doesn't automatically produce competence, and treating the two as interchangeable is one of the most common ways good managers lose good employees. The path forward isn't more praise or more patience. It's specific, structured coaching aimed at the actual gap in front of you.

Need help building out a coaching plan or a manager training session on performance diagnosis? BizCoachGurus works with leaders to turn exactly these situations into growth stories instead of exit interviews.

Trust • Teach • Transform www.BizCoachGurus.com

#SkillVsWill #PeopleManagement #EmployeeCoaching #ManagerTraining #PerformanceManagement #LeadershipDevelopment #HRConsulting #WorkplaceCulture #EmployeeEngagement #CoachingCulture #ManagerTips #TalentDevelopment #WorkEthic #FeedbackCulture #HRLeadership #BizCoachGurus #TrustTeachTransform #LeadershipCoaching

Sources

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Top 4 Reasons Employees Take a New Job – And How Employers Can Respond

-
Image
The Top 4 Reasons Employees Take a New Job – And How Employers Can Respond In today’s competitive job market, attracting and retaining top talent is more challenging than ever. A recent Gallup study highlights the four key reasons why employees choose to leave their current roles for new opportunities. Understanding these drivers can help businesses refine their hiring and retention strategies to create a workplace that employees truly want to be part of. Key Highlights from Gallup’s Findings: ✅ Higher pay and benefits remain the top reason employees seek new jobs. ✅ Work-life balance and well-being are more important than ever. ✅ Career growth opportunities significantly impact employee retention. ✅ Company culture and purpose influence employees' job choices. 1. Increased Pay and Benefits 💰 Key Insight: 64% of employees say pay is a major factor in their decision to take a new job. Competitive compensation remains crucial in today’s workforce. How Employers Can Respond: ✔️...
Read more

How to Make People Matter in Business — Even When These Truths Exist

-
Image
Let’s be honest. Most companies say “people are our greatest asset,” but then act like HR is a liability. CEOs view HR as a checkbox. CCOs see brand as a consumer facing experience CFOs see it as an expense with no ROI. Culture is too often shaped by who signs the paychecks — not by shared purpose or people-first practices. If we want to build workplaces that truly  work  — for employees and the bottom line — we have to start by telling the truth. Here are just a few of the hard realities leaders face every day: Feedback rarely makes it to the people who need it most. Company values vanish during budget cuts. Engagement surveys often smooth over deeper issues or go performatively addressed. Top talent leaves Exits are often predictable and preventable. Workplace conflicts often start with compensation inequities. And HR wins? They're mostly invisible. These aren't symptoms of bad intent. They’re symptoms of misaligned priorities. So how do we make people  really  mat...
Read more

Florida Employment Law Updates for Small Businesses in 2025

-
Image
As 2025 unfolds, small businesses in Florida must stay informed about recent changes in state employment laws to ensure compliance and maintain smooth operations. Below is a summary of key updates effective this year: 1. State Preemption of Local Employment Regulations Effective July 1, 2024, Florida enacted legislation that centralizes the authority to regulate employment practices at the state level, preempting local governments from enacting their own employment-related ordinances. This means that only the state can set rules regarding employment practices, including regulations related to heat exposure for private employers. Small businesses should review their policies to ensure they align with state laws, as local ordinances may no longer apply. 2. Minimum Wage Increase Continuing its scheduled increases, Florida's minimum wage will rise to $14.00 per hour on September 30, 2025. This is part of the state's plan to incrementally increase the minimum wage annually until it ...
Read more